Google Books is So Good. But Imperfect

I really like Google Books.

Lots of times, when I’ve considered buying a book that isn’t in the library, I’ve just read a chapter or two on Google Books and made my decision. Or when trying to remember just the way someone described something, I can find the book and read for myself:

“My very photogenic mother died in a freak accident (picnic, lightning) when I was three, and save for a pocket of warmth in the darkest past, nothing of her subsists within the hollows and dells of my memory.” – Lolita, by Nabokov

Such a great mix of quick humor and evocative metaphor. Thank you google books!

But then, it has its problems. According to this article, the metadata is completely unreliable.

That is, if you want to see whether the 1956 edition differed from the 1982 edition, you’re probably out of luck. If you want to see how people talked about New Orleans before Katrina, look elsewhere.

Google does show data about the dates of its books, but it’s all screwed up, as is the category of the book.

An example from the article: “A search on “Internet” in books published before 1950 produces 527 results.”

And more:

“An edition of Moby Dick is labeled Computers; The Cat Lover’s Book of Fascinating Facts falls under Technology & Engineering. And a catalog of copyright entries from the Library of Congress is listed under Drama….”


2 Responses to Google Books is So Good. But Imperfect

  1. JB September 2, 2009 at 3:47 pm #

    They need to make a version of Google Image Search for books, to get the tagging straightened up.

  2. Mary Rossen February 17, 2012 at 5:06 am #

    Well, Google books has solved your problem for you – you now cant read a Google book at all@! My browser, IE, shows a LARGE hanging down chad full of useless info on the left side of the Google book page which intrudes clear into the book page itself! What idiot at Google came up with that one? Or are they now preventing anyone from seeing their Google books, because that is what their chad accomplishes!

    Just close Google books, because its useless now as they have it. All we need in this world are more ads, more chads, more useless add-ons – pretty soon that wont be room for life itself! Then Google will be beside the point by its own design, just as it has made
    their Google book page now! What is going on!? I

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe without commenting

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes